Selvaine Quarterly
10 American Boat Shoe Brands That Quietly Hollowed Out — And The One Pair That Rebuilt The 1935 Spec
Sperry Top-Sider — sold 2012, production moved to China
Paul Sperry drew the original boat shoe in 1935 because his dog kept slipping on the deck of his sailboat. He cut siping into the rubber sole with a pocket knife to imitate the way his dog's paws gripped wet teak. The pattern stayed the same for 77 years.
Then in 2012, Wolverine Worldwide bought Sperry and moved production overseas. Within 18 months, the leather went from full-grain to corrected. The hardware was downgraded. The laces were replaced with a synthetic cord that frays inside two weeks. The construction switched from stitched to glued.
Sperry is now owned by The Aldo Group of Canada. The price stayed at roughly $110. Somebody is keeping the difference, and it isn't the cobblers — there aren't any cobblers anymore.
L.L.Bean Hand-Sewn Moccasins — lifetime guarantee silently revoked
For most of a century, L.L.Bean's hand-sewn moccasins came with the cleanest guarantee in American retail: if it ever fails, send it back. The handsewns were assembled in Maine. The leather was tanned in New England. You could call the company on a Sunday and a real person picked up.
Around 2014, production shifted overseas. The "lifetime" guarantee was quietly replaced with a "limited" one. The change didn't appear in any press release.
Bass Weejun — sold to Wall Street, sent to China
The Weejun was the loafer that defined the patrician college kid for forty years. Made in Wilton, Maine, until the early 2000s, when private equity bought the brand and shut down the American factory.
The current Weejun is made overseas, sells for $79 at Macy's, and falls apart in 14 months.
Sebago Docksider — gone, 2018
Sebago made the Docksider in Maine for nearly seventy years. The canvas boat shoe was a quiet classic — patrician without being precious, the kind of thing your father wore on the Vineyard.
The Maine factory closed in 2018. The brand still exists on paper. The shoes are made in Italy now and rebranded for the European market. The American Docksider is no longer produced.
Allen Edmonds — foreign-owned, leather quality dropped on every model
Allen Edmonds was the last American men's dress shoe brand most of us trusted. Then it sold itself in 2016. The craftsmanship hasn't recovered since. The leather on the high-end models feels different now. The lasts run differently. The recrafting program — which used to be the entire reason to buy from them — is now slower, more expensive, and frequently declined.
Cole Haan — private equity, disposable for over a decade
Apax Partners bought Cole Haan from Nike in 2013. Within five years, the brand was selling sneakers and disposable dress shoes priced like investment-grade footwear. The leather is corrected. The construction is glued. The shoes are made in Vietnam. They use the phrase "designed by American craftsmen" in their marketing.
Johnston & Murphy — quietly degraded
Worn by nearly every American president for 175 years. The current product line is sold at Macy's, made overseas, and constructed using the same glued-and-rebadged methods every other "heritage" brand has adopted. The shoes are not the shoes our fathers wore.
Florsheim — the Imperial wingtip, hollowed out
Florsheim Imperials were the standard-issue American dress shoe through the 1970s. The Chicago factory closed in 1992. The current Florsheim line is owned by Weyco Group and manufactured in India and China. The Imperial name still appears on boxes. The construction inside the box is unrecognizable.
Abercrombie & Fitch — the original sporting outfitter, gone
Before it was a teenage perfume store, Abercrombie & Fitch was the outfitter that sold Hemingway his rifles and Teddy Roosevelt his hunting boots. Their Chicago store carried the same boat shoe Paul Sperry licensed to them in the 1960s.
$20 in 1969 is roughly $175 today. That is what these shoes were always supposed to cost.
The current production batch is available now.
Selvaine Marlin — built to the original 1935 spec, priced where these shoes were always supposed to be
I started Selvaine because I got tired of the list above. I am not going to claim my shoes are made in Maine. They are not. They are made overseas. Every other brand on this list lies about their manufacturing — I am not going to add my name to that list to sell you a $45 boat shoe.
What I can tell you is what was rebuilt:
- The 1935 Sperry pattern, as Paul Sperry originally drew it
- Two-tone construction with a real leather saddle and heel counter
- Real rawhide leather laces — not the synthetic cord that frays in two weeks
- Siped sole cut deep, the way the original gripped wet teak
- $45 a pair, plus $15 ground shipping. The price these shoes were always supposed to cost before everyone decided they could mark them up 400% and call it heritage.
- 30-day domestic return. Send them back to a US address. No store credit. No ship-to-China runaround.
If you were burned by Sperry in 2014 and you have been wearing whatever Costco had in stock for the last decade, this is the shoe you remember. It is not made by the brand you remember. The brand you remember does not exist anymore.
I made this one because nobody else was going to.
The 1935 spec, rebuilt. $45.
What the cohort has said
30 days. US return address. No tricks.
Wear them on the dock. Wear them to the cookout. Wear them to your daughter's wedding rehearsal.
If they aren't the boat shoes you remember from before 2012, send them back to the address printed on the box. Domestic. No store credit. No ship-to-China runaround.
Claim Your Pair →